Kitty Murtagh in Nantucket

$5.00 Burger night every Tuesday, can't beat that deal. Don't want a beef burger same thing goes for a chicken patty burger.

It is the place that I had to ask my money change and waited for it more than ten minutes and when I had my change back the service lady apologized that no one told her we were waiting our change!!! Do you we have to ask for that?? Isn’t it up to me leave it as tip or do you decide always for everyone too?

Kitchen was super fast. Wait staff was attentive. Menu is small and priced to the local market (but way too high). I like the off street parking. Everyone seems to know the customers. I had the seafood pie. It was really more of pie and salmon than anything. It was not a light flaky pasty as promised and really was more than 1/2 of the pie. In terms of seafood it had everything listed but really only I piece of everything but the salmon. Not impressed.

Fun place, great food. I wish I lived in Nantucket, I'd go all the time

Great burger night!

We came across this place when arriving in Nantucket for the first time.Not as many places were open when we were there but this one was and it didn’t disappoint. Great food, great drinks, and the other places lost out because we’ll always stop here first on future visits. The crew was also colossally friendly and helpful with advice for the rest of our stay.

Overall was a good experience... food came fast. Waiter ?¿?

Tuesday burger night is a must do for locals during off season. And wing "happy hours" are great too. Great food and people all year. One of Nantucket's best values. And finds.

An awesome atmosphere coupled with delicious food make Kitty Murtaghs a must for any foodie!

Pretty nice place and environment to get something to eat

This is an excellent Irish pub that makes you feel like you're in Ireland.

Good burgers

Excellent

The food is high quality and it doesn't break the bank, the drinks aren't super expensive either

Not...Not an Irish pub. Food way too expensive, Staff curt and worst of all is its "Irish" label. WTF is wrong with googling Ireland and looking at an Irish bar then basing your "Irish bar" on it???Seriously it's as Irish as Spaghetti

I will give it a 5 star

Food and drink are English centered, but in an American way (as in no kidney in the steak pie). Service was friendly, but slow. Food was good.

Great meeting place with friends. Great hamburgers. An undiscovered Nantucket treasure

Great food and service

Irish pub. Local hangout. Great service clean and comfortable. I had the triple medillion tenderloin. I asked for medium rare, it wasn't even close more like medium well to well done hardly any pink. That said I still quite enjoyed it . I would order it again to give it a second chance.

Always good

Nothing more Nantucket than dinner or drinks here at Kitty’s ! Roaring fireplace and fantastic meals ... try the chicken dumpling splitters or any of their pies !

Always good, always fun! This is the perfect place to escape the crowds in town and still have amazing food! There is so much more than the traditional Irish food on this menu. Upstairs is a restaurant bar with a pleasant atmosphere and billiards tables BUT downstairs there is a pub style cozy restaurant with a salad bar and some of the best food on island. The ‘Kitty’s” is located mid-island down a side street from the big Stop and Shop but it is worth the trip out there even if you are staying in town or at the marina. It is family friendly and one of Nantucket's best values ⛵

As fun as the upstairs dining room might be to some, I prefer the downstairs dining room which quieter, more intimate, etc. However, I would suggest making reservations for the down stairs, as they have been booked up before. Definitely try to go on Tuesdays from like Sept till about April or May ish. They have $5 burger/grilled chicken sandwich night every night.

Pub was cool. Food was meh. Don't think when the waiter says something isn't great that all of a sudden you're going to have an extraordinary experience. I wanted the chicken pot pie. He said it was kinda dry. Guess what. It was kinda dry. Not entirely a waste, but not GREAT. Fish and chips were kinda meh too. The vibe was great though. Go in with "bar food" expectations, you'll either be spot on or pleasantly surprised.

Burger night is a great deal off season

This is a awesome restraint. Owned by a couple from Ireland. The food is authentic and just like you would get in Ireland. The price is definitely reasonable for the island.

Being from California, having a wood fireplace was surely a nice treat! Kitty Murtaghs atmosphere would keep me coming back. I had the steak and mushroom pie, highly recommend. It was delicious!

Good portions. No long wait. Good menu. Food was very good.

Friendly pub atmosphere with good food and family friendly dining area.

Good service. Good company.

Good food and great service!

Went for $5 burgers. Waitress was not nice at all. Messed up our bill and was angry we wanted it changed. Keep an eye out the EGG IS $1 NOT $2. It wasn't that big of a deal but the way our waitress handled it made it a big deal. Probably never coming back. Afraid she will spit in our food

Great service delicious food. The pork schnitzel with capers and lemon, tomatoes and fingerling potatoes.

Amy is the only reason I come here. She is simply the best!

Casual place, good food and drinks

Sunday brunch is amazing. Great atmosphere for family and friends..love kittys my favorite bar/restaurant on nantucket

Great atmosphere, disappointed with the shepard's pie, runny potatoes and sparse meat filling. Seasonal beers great, friendly staff.

A great undiscovered place. Fab sandwiches and very reasonable prices.

Best deal on island , $5 burger night, good food and good staff . Great family night out that won't break the bank.

Love this place! Great atmosphere, friendly staff and the food is always on point.

Great year-round steak and upscale pub fare. Fantastic atmosphere and billiards as well.

Awesome menu with creative choices. Had a half sandwich (fried green tomatoe/bacon on grilled sour dough. Mayonnaise aioli worth mentioning. Soup of beef barley. Side of onion rings.A couple of Bass Ales and I was very satisfied!

We were lucky to find this jewel. Not fancy but really nice. More locals than tourists which says a lot. Made to feel welcome. We had great food at reasonable cost. Good selection of beers. Doesn't disappoint. Try this!!

Great pub atmosphere, 2 pool tables off the bar and seated restaurant up and down stairs.

Nantucket Island's only Irish restaurant. Fun times and phenomenal food

Good food. Cozy atmosphere

Yummy French onion soup. Reasonable prices.

Family friendly service good lunch good TV ALL AROUND POOL KIDS FRIENDLY HAD AGOOD TIME.

Very good